William wrote: ↑Mon Dec 12, 2022 8:03 pm
[
Replying to myth-one.com in post #1343]
The tangent you have gone off on, doesn't appear to connect with what I have been arguing.
There is no mention in The First Creation Story of "angels", rebellious or otherwise or mention of YHVH creating humans in order to replace creations which failed in any commission, or indeed, any commission from YHVH given to such entities.
Can you tie your argument in with The First Creation Story, that it would make sense of your tangential argument?
Thanks.
So we will probably learn that YHVH's way is the best way by trying our way and failing.
Your argument has it that YHVH created two specific species, one which failed, and the other which will somehow learn that YHVH's 'way' is 'the best' - hardly convincing, since the argument also includes as part of "YHVH's way" is to create mechanisms which ultimately fail.
There are two separate type of species defined in the Bible -- natural (or physical) and spiritual.
There is not much info about spiritual bodied beings because it didn't concern us.
In the beginning, God created the heavens and the earth. Satan was given rule over the earth and he had a host of angels assigned to the earth under His command.
But Satan wanted more power and glory and wanted to be equal to the most high God, so he and some angels under his command rebelled against God.
There was war in heaven, God prevailed, and Satan and the rebels were cast back to the earth.
As a result of their abandoning their earthly responsibilities, the earth had become formless, empty, and dark.
God then returned to the decimated earth and began the recreation of a decimated earth in Genesis 1:3 by turning the lights back on.
Mankind was created in this recreation. So man is Plan B.
In the recreation God did not create more spiritual beings and risk being stuck with more rebels for eternity. He created a mortal being called man a little lower than the angels. Man can chose to become equal unto the angels and replace the original earthly caretakers.
In both cases, God created beings well equipped for their jobs. One attribute required was freedom of choice.
Making some poor decisions led to the system "failures". Mankind goes through a taste of life and then decides to accept or reject everlasting life. Thus the system involving mankind should produce angels who are less likely to rebel against God.
Those who are unsure can opt out by choosing the second death.