Preamble
This post hopes to demonstrate that morality and obedience are not the same thing.
Seems so simple to me, but not so simple for many Christians who defend the actions of God.
I have been mostly focusing on the story of the "Fall Of Mankind" where God first commands obedience to a human. I quickly noticed that no moral justification was offered for God's Divine Command.
Morality concerns whether an action is right or wrong, good or bad, by using moral principles and guidelines.
Obedience simply means following a command. A person can obey a command without that obedience making the action moral.
The Nuremberg Trials illustrate this distinction.
Obedience to an authority was not accepted by the judges as sufficient moral justification for the defendant's horrible genocides.
The same distinction applies to Adam and Eve.
God commanded them not to eat the fruit, but the command itself provided no independent moral reason explaining why eating the fruit was morally wrong.
The command established what God wanted them to obey. It did not establish morality. I sometimes think of the moral theory as "might makes right".
Hitler sure had the might.. And so did God.
The world didn't consider that Hitler's might made his commands "morally right".
QUESTION TO CHRISTIANS:
Do you consider God's command moral, and if so, why?
Definitions
Morality: principles or judgments concerning what is right or wrong, good or bad, permissible or impermissible.
Obedience: following a command or instruction given by an authority.
Authority: the power or right to give commands and require obedience.
Moral authority: authority claimed to determine what people ought or ought not do morally.
Moral justification: a reason explaining why an action is morally right, wrong, good, bad, permissible, or impermissible.
Divine command theory: the philosophical view that moral obligations are grounded in God’s commands.
Moral obligation:an action one is morally required to perform or avoid.
Independent moral reason: a moral justification that does not depend solely on the authority issuing the command.
Relevant Bible Verses
Genesis 2:16–17: “And the LORD God commanded the man, ‘You may freely eat of every tree of the garden; but of the tree of the knowledge of good and evil you shall not eat, for in the day that you eat of it you shall die.’”
Genesis 3:2–3: “The woman said to the serpent, ‘We may eat of the fruit of the trees in the garden; but God said, “You shall not eat of the fruit that is in the middle of the garden, nor shall you touch it, or you shall die.”’”
Genesis 3:17: “And to the man he said, ‘Because you have listened to the voice of your wife, and have eaten of the tree about which I commanded you, “You shall not eat of it,” cursed is the ground because of you; in toil you shall eat of it all the days of your life.’”
Argument
P1: Adam and Eve’s command provided authority, but no independent moral justification.
P2: Morality requires moral justification, not merely authority.
C: Therefore, God’s command to Adam and Eve was not moral.
Was God's Command Moral?
Moderator: Moderators
-
Ray the atheist
- Sage
- Posts: 682
- Joined: Wed Apr 01, 2026 12:28 pm
- Has thanked: 15 times
- Been thanked: 76 times
Was God's Command Moral?
Post #1I study religiously motivated reasoning. I'm an agnostic atheist and I don't believe in the supernatural or superstitions. I genuinely want to engage your ideas charitably and respectfully. I value critical thinking, empathy, intellectual honesty, and civil disagreement. I am committed to understanding each other’s arguments, remaining open to correction, and discussing arguments rather than attack each other.
-
Ray the atheist
- Sage
- Posts: 682
- Joined: Wed Apr 01, 2026 12:28 pm
- Has thanked: 15 times
- Been thanked: 76 times
Re: Was God's Command Moral?
Post #11[Replying to Bradskii in post #10]
I won't force you to.
It's ok if you don't want to discuss the bible.Obviously not, as I don't believe He exists in the first place. But if I was a Christian then I'd really try not to discuss the problem of evil with anyone because I can't see how it can be reconciled with an all loving, morally perfect God. As regards situations like the Amalekites, then I wouldn't be able to accept that as an accurate depiction of what God wanted. I'd treat it as I would treat the flood - stories told by mortal men to warn us about a wrathful immortal God.
I won't force you to.
I study religiously motivated reasoning. I'm an agnostic atheist and I don't believe in the supernatural or superstitions. I genuinely want to engage your ideas charitably and respectfully. I value critical thinking, empathy, intellectual honesty, and civil disagreement. I am committed to understanding each other’s arguments, remaining open to correction, and discussing arguments rather than attack each other.
- Bradskii
- Apprentice
- Posts: 161
- Joined: Sun Jul 04, 2021 8:07 am
- Has thanked: 15 times
- Been thanked: 71 times
Re: Was God's Command Moral?
Post #12I've no problem in discussing it...Ray the atheist wrote: ↑Fri Oct 16, 2026 8:36 am [Replying to Bradskii in post #10]
It's ok if you don't want to discuss the bible.Obviously not, as I don't believe He exists in the first place. But if I was a Christian then I'd really try not to discuss the problem of evil with anyone because I can't see how it can be reconciled with an all loving, morally perfect God. As regards situations like the Amalekites, then I wouldn't be able to accept that as an accurate depiction of what God wanted. I'd treat it as I would treat the flood - stories told by mortal men to warn us about a wrathful immortal God.
I won't force you to.
- tam
- Savant
- Posts: 7083
- Joined: Fri Jun 19, 2015 4:59 pm
- Has thanked: 408 times
- Been thanked: 376 times
- Contact:
Re: Was God's Command Moral?
Post #13Peace to you,
He told them not to eat from the tree, because if they did, they would die.
"Don't touch the hot stove, or you will burn your hand."
"Don't eat from the Tree of knowing good and bad, or you will die."
Peace again.
I would also like to point out that God didn't just give a command; He also gave the reason for the command.Mr E wrote: ↑Tue Oct 06, 2026 8:48 am [Replying to Ray the atheist in post #3]
Ah... so then let's stipulate that "Don't eat from the tree" was also a safety issue, with no need for any sort of moral justification.Interesting question.
The proposition "Don't touch the hot stove" is not about morality, it's about safety.
So, my answer is "No, I don't think it needs any moral justification."
That's the thing about Fathers. Sometimes they tell you to do, or not to do certain things for our own good, without the need to justify, or explain themselves.
He told them not to eat from the tree, because if they did, they would die.
"Don't touch the hot stove, or you will burn your hand."
"Don't eat from the Tree of knowing good and bad, or you will die."
Peace again.
- Non-religious Christian spirituality
- For Christ (who is the Spirit)
- For Christ (who is the Spirit)
-
BruceLeiter
- Sage
- Posts: 660
- Joined: Thu Nov 06, 2025 3:39 pm
- Been thanked: 19 times
Re: Was God's Command Moral?
Post #14[Replying to Ray the atheist in post #1]
"P1: Adam and Eve’s command provided authority, but no independent moral justification.
P2: Morality requires moral justification, not merely authority.
C: Therefore, God’s command to Adam and Eve was not moral."
@Ray the atheist, your reasoning is fallible, because it approaches the question of morality and obedience from a human viewpoint like the Nuremburg judges and, horror of horrors, equates God's command with Hitler's.
Because God is Adam and Eve's Creator and ours, he has every right to require limits on our actions because he is God, and we not. Therefore, he has no need to justify to us his commands; they are for our good and, as a result, just and merciful.
"P1: Adam and Eve’s command provided authority, but no independent moral justification.
P2: Morality requires moral justification, not merely authority.
C: Therefore, God’s command to Adam and Eve was not moral."
@Ray the atheist, your reasoning is fallible, because it approaches the question of morality and obedience from a human viewpoint like the Nuremburg judges and, horror of horrors, equates God's command with Hitler's.
Because God is Adam and Eve's Creator and ours, he has every right to require limits on our actions because he is God, and we not. Therefore, he has no need to justify to us his commands; they are for our good and, as a result, just and merciful.
-
Ray the atheist
- Sage
- Posts: 682
- Joined: Wed Apr 01, 2026 12:28 pm
- Has thanked: 15 times
- Been thanked: 76 times
Re: Was God's Command Moral?
Post #15[Replying to BruceLeiter in post #14]
You may use a more divine system of logic.
I follow the quite human rules of logic.@Ray the atheist, your reasoning is fallible, because it approaches the question of morality and obedience from a human viewpoint like the Nuremburg judges and, horror of horrors, equates God's command with Hitler's.
You may use a more divine system of logic.
I study religiously motivated reasoning. I'm an agnostic atheist and I don't believe in the supernatural or superstitions. I genuinely want to engage your ideas charitably and respectfully. I value critical thinking, empathy, intellectual honesty, and civil disagreement. I am committed to understanding each other’s arguments, remaining open to correction, and discussing arguments rather than attack each other.
-
Ray the atheist
- Sage
- Posts: 682
- Joined: Wed Apr 01, 2026 12:28 pm
- Has thanked: 15 times
- Been thanked: 76 times
Re: Was God's Command Moral?
Post #16[Replying to BruceLeiter in post #14]
"Might makes right" means whoever has the greatest power gets to decide what is morally right.
It's disastrous because:
1. Power replaces morality. Strength, not fairness or justice, determines what is acceptable.
2. Oppression becomes justified. Powerful people can exploit, enslave, torture, or kill weaker people simply because they can.
3. Victims have no moral protection. Their rights depend entirely on whether someone stronger chooses to respect them.
4. Abuse becomes self-justifying. The powerful can declare their actions righteous simply because they possess the authority to impose them.
5. Moral progress becomes impossible. Challenging injustice becomes wrong whenever those responsible have enough power to suppress opposition.
Ultimately, might makes right doesn't establish morality. It eliminates morality and replaces it with domination.
You seem to be advancing the idea that God's might makes right.Because God is Adam and Eve's Creator and ours, he has every right to require limits on our actions because he is God, and we not. Therefore, he has no need to justify to us his commands; they are for our good and, as a result, just and merciful.
"Might makes right" means whoever has the greatest power gets to decide what is morally right.
It's disastrous because:
1. Power replaces morality. Strength, not fairness or justice, determines what is acceptable.
2. Oppression becomes justified. Powerful people can exploit, enslave, torture, or kill weaker people simply because they can.
3. Victims have no moral protection. Their rights depend entirely on whether someone stronger chooses to respect them.
4. Abuse becomes self-justifying. The powerful can declare their actions righteous simply because they possess the authority to impose them.
5. Moral progress becomes impossible. Challenging injustice becomes wrong whenever those responsible have enough power to suppress opposition.
Ultimately, might makes right doesn't establish morality. It eliminates morality and replaces it with domination.
I study religiously motivated reasoning. I'm an agnostic atheist and I don't believe in the supernatural or superstitions. I genuinely want to engage your ideas charitably and respectfully. I value critical thinking, empathy, intellectual honesty, and civil disagreement. I am committed to understanding each other’s arguments, remaining open to correction, and discussing arguments rather than attack each other.

