Do Catholics promote contraception?

Ethics, Morality, and Sin

Moderator: Moderators

Flail

Do Catholics promote contraception?

Post #1

Post by Flail »

I am told that the Catholic church teaches against contraception yet promotes abstinence in fertile periods for the female...isn't that contraception?

Personally I favor abortion as a women's choice and think it would be acceptable behavior to God under the right circumstances....an unwanted child...single parent...rape....young parent without parenting skills....child with deformity or other problems who would have a life of suffering.....It is a tough subject however, and should be left to the parents and not a group of men in funny clothes.

User avatar
micatala
Site Supporter
Posts: 8338
Joined: Sun Feb 27, 2005 2:04 pm

Re: Do Catholics promote contraception?

Post #21

Post by micatala »

Moderator Warning

This is not only an unproductive one-liner, but most people would consider it inflammatory. There is really no need for a comment like this.
Flail wrote:
Lucia wrote:
cnorman18 wrote:There are two, and only two, methods of birth control acceptable to the Catholic Church: (1) Periodic abstinence when the woman is capable of conception, and (2) total celibacy.

Or, as a musician friend of mine put it, "rhythm and blues."

The idea that sex is only for procreation in humans is provably false. Other mammals are only interested in sex when the female is fertile; at other times, they exhibit no interest. Humans, not so. We like sex ANYTIME. If one believes that God designed this arrangement, it should be obvious that sex is intended for pleasure as well as making babies.

Christianity has always had a bit of a bee in its bonnet about sex, as if sexual sins were somehow more heinous than other sins and as if sexual desire and sexuality itself were somehow evil. Weird.

Judaism regards sexuality as a blessing, not a curse - and celibacy as not exactly a sin, but pretty damn stupid. There is no such thing as a Jewish monk or nun.

For the record, many Orthodox Jews have the same attitude toward contraception as Catholics. They tend to have huge families, too.
Also, sex is proven to have medical benefits :)
Apart from the possibility of its resulting in successful pregnancy and childbirth, sex has a wide range of health benefits including relief from stress, more immunity through increased immunoglobulin A, reduced risk of heart attack and of prostate cancer, and sounder sleep.
(Source: Wiki)

And I don't have any facts on this, but I'm still willing to bet that people who have a healthy and active sex life are happier O:)
Having anal sex with children controls birth and is obviously a method approved by the Church.
" . . . the line separating good and evil passes, not through states, nor between classes, nor between political parties either, but right through every human heart . . . ." Alexander Solzhenitsyn

Flail

Re: Do Catholics promote contraception?

Post #22

Post by Flail »

micatala wrote:Moderator Warning

This is not only an unproductive one-liner, but most people would consider it inflammatory. There is really no need for a comment like this.
Flail wrote:
Lucia wrote:
cnorman18 wrote:There are two, and only two, methods of birth control acceptable to the Catholic Church: (1) Periodic abstinence when the woman is capable of conception, and (2) total celibacy.

Or, as a musician friend of mine put it, "rhythm and blues."

The idea that sex is only for procreation in humans is provably false. Other mammals are only interested in sex when the female is fertile; at other times, they exhibit no interest. Humans, not so. We like sex ANYTIME. If one believes that God designed this arrangement, it should be obvious that sex is intended for pleasure as well as making babies.

Christianity has always had a bit of a bee in its bonnet about sex, as if sexual sins were somehow more heinous than other sins and as if sexual desire and sexuality itself were somehow evil. Weird.

Judaism regards sexuality as a blessing, not a curse - and celibacy as not exactly a sin, but pretty damn stupid. There is no such thing as a Jewish monk or nun.

For the record, many Orthodox Jews have the same attitude toward contraception as Catholics. They tend to have huge families, too.
Also, sex is proven to have medical benefits :)
Apart from the possibility of its resulting in successful pregnancy and childbirth, sex has a wide range of health benefits including relief from stress, more immunity through increased immunoglobulin A, reduced risk of heart attack and of prostate cancer, and sounder sleep.
(Source: Wiki)

And I don't have any facts on this, but I'm still willing to bet that people who have a healthy and active sex life are happier O:)
Having anal sex with children controls birth and is obviously a method approved by the Church.
very, very inflamatory...

WinePusher

Re: Do Catholics promote contraception?

Post #23

Post by WinePusher »

Flail wrote:
micatala wrote:Moderator Warning

This is not only an unproductive one-liner, but most people would consider it inflammatory. There is really no need for a comment like this.
Flail wrote:
Lucia wrote:
cnorman18 wrote:There are two, and only two, methods of birth control acceptable to the Catholic Church: (1) Periodic abstinence when the woman is capable of conception, and (2) total celibacy.

Or, as a musician friend of mine put it, "rhythm and blues."

The idea that sex is only for procreation in humans is provably false. Other mammals are only interested in sex when the female is fertile; at other times, they exhibit no interest. Humans, not so. We like sex ANYTIME. If one believes that God designed this arrangement, it should be obvious that sex is intended for pleasure as well as making babies.

Christianity has always had a bit of a bee in its bonnet about sex, as if sexual sins were somehow more heinous than other sins and as if sexual desire and sexuality itself were somehow evil. Weird.

Judaism regards sexuality as a blessing, not a curse - and celibacy as not exactly a sin, but pretty damn stupid. There is no such thing as a Jewish monk or nun.

For the record, many Orthodox Jews have the same attitude toward contraception as Catholics. They tend to have huge families, too.
Also, sex is proven to have medical benefits :)
Apart from the possibility of its resulting in successful pregnancy and childbirth, sex has a wide range of health benefits including relief from stress, more immunity through increased immunoglobulin A, reduced risk of heart attack and of prostate cancer, and sounder sleep.
(Source: Wiki)

And I don't have any facts on this, but I'm still willing to bet that people who have a healthy and active sex life are happier O:)
Having anal sex with children controls birth and is obviously a method approved by the Church.
very, very inflamatory...
typical slander from people like you.....

User avatar
McCulloch
Site Supporter
Posts: 24063
Joined: Mon May 02, 2005 9:10 pm
Location: Toronto, ON, CA
Been thanked: 3 times

Re: Do Catholics promote contraception?

Post #24

Post by McCulloch »

:warning: Moderator Caution
Flail wrote: very, very inflamatory...
This post in no way moves the debate forward nor does it foster respect. It is unworthy of this site.

Please do not comment on the moderating. Use a PM if you feel the need to comment on the moderating.

When the moderators feel the rules have been violated, a notice will frequently occur within the thread where the violation occurred, pointing out the violation and perhaps providing other moderator comments. Moderator warnings and comments are made publicly, within the thread, so that all members may see when and how the rules are being interpreted and enforced. However, note that any challenges or replies to moderator comments or warnings should be made via Private Message. This is so that threads do not get derailed into discussions about the rules.
Examine everything carefully; hold fast to that which is good.
First Epistle to the Church of the Thessalonians
The truth will make you free.
Gospel of John

Flail

Re: Do Catholics promote contraception?

Post #25

Post by Flail »

winepusher wrote:
Flail wrote:
micatala wrote:Moderator Warning

This is not only an unproductive one-liner, but most people would consider it inflammatory. There is really no need for a comment like this.
Flail wrote:
Lucia wrote:
cnorman18 wrote:There are two, and only two, methods of birth control acceptable to the Catholic Church: (1) Periodic abstinence when the woman is capable of conception, and (2) total celibacy.

Or, as a musician friend of mine put it, "rhythm and blues."

The idea that sex is only for procreation in humans is provably false. Other mammals are only interested in sex when the female is fertile; at other times, they exhibit no interest. Humans, not so. We like sex ANYTIME. If one believes that God designed this arrangement, it should be obvious that sex is intended for pleasure as well as making babies.

Christianity has always had a bit of a bee in its bonnet about sex, as if sexual sins were somehow more heinous than other sins and as if sexual desire and sexuality itself were somehow evil. Weird.

Judaism regards sexuality as a blessing, not a curse - and celibacy as not exactly a sin, but pretty damn stupid. There is no such thing as a Jewish monk or nun.

For the record, many Orthodox Jews have the same attitude toward contraception as Catholics. They tend to have huge families, too.
Also, sex is proven to have medical benefits :)
Apart from the possibility of its resulting in successful pregnancy and childbirth, sex has a wide range of health benefits including relief from stress, more immunity through increased immunoglobulin A, reduced risk of heart attack and of prostate cancer, and sounder sleep.
(Source: Wiki)

And I don't have any facts on this, but I'm still willing to bet that people who have a healthy and active sex life are happier O:)
Having anal sex with children controls birth and is obviously a method approved by the Church.
very, very inflamatory...
typical slander from people like you.....
Truth is a defense to slander...and I don't believe we've met.

Post Reply