Are There Any True Christian Denominations?

Exploring the details of Christianity

Moderator: Moderators

User avatar
BeHereNow
Site Supporter
Posts: 584
Joined: Sun Nov 21, 2004 6:18 pm
Location: Maryland
Has thanked: 2 times

Are There Any True Christian Denominations?

Post #1

Post by BeHereNow »

Are any Christian denominations “true” Christian?

seen da light, in a separate thread, has told us some major denominations, in his opinion, are not true Christian. Among these would be Catholics, Eastern Orthodox, Anglicans, Lutherans, Presbyterians, Continental Reformed, and Methodists.
Here is his reasoning:
seen da light
I would like to foremostly agree with the fact that certain demoninations aren't in fact true Christianity.lets take for example the catholic church.
Nowhere does it tell christians to have a pope.Nowhere does it tell us to make church such a pompous precession of fancy dressed people.
What the catholic church does,is no where in scripture.It is traditions that have been added to the word of god.
another example is of the methodist church.Here they baptise babies. the commandments are clear ,to repent and be baptised.can babies repent?they don't even know spiritual right from wrong yet.so thus it is a tradition that is questionable when compared to the biblical model(note that is how you compare churches)

I think that a biblical church is the correct demnomination.
So most likely a charasmatic modern church who only go after what god says and are guided by prayer as opposed to human planning.
A denomination that follows the word of God down to the letter.
a biblical church...

any church, whether it be of any denomination, that if compared to the biblical model,is similar or exactly the same,with no traditions added to it.
that is a true denomination.
Denominations shouldn't exist, but it has been worldly traditions added to churches that have caused people to break away from it.because they have seen that it isn't the biblical.


So my comment to him was/is, please give an example of a true Christian church.

Please tell me which church “follows the word of God down to the letter”, including being “guided by prayer as opposed to human planning”.
I know a few denominations which may come close to meeting his criteria, but know of none that meet it.

He has not been willing to name such a denomination unless I PM or start a new thread, so here we are.

It seems a charismatic modern church might be a good candidate, but of course they disagree about the correct application of speaking in tongues and only a very few handle snakes, re: [And these signs shall follow them that believe; In my name shall they cast out devils; they shall speak with new tongues; They shall take up serpents; and if they drink any deadly thing, it shall not hurt them; they shall lay hands on the sick, and they shall recover.]

One criteria I will be looking for in seen da light’s true Christian church is observance of the foot washing ceremony. As the Bible says “If I then, your Lord and Master, have washed your feet; ye also ought to wash one another's feet.”

So seen da light, are there any true Christian denominations?

User avatar
McCulloch
Site Supporter
Posts: 24063
Joined: Mon May 02, 2005 9:10 pm
Location: Toronto, ON, CA
Been thanked: 3 times

Post #2

Post by McCulloch »

I suspect that every denomination and no denomination are the true Christian denomination.

Every Christian denomination started as a recognition of something missing or something wrong with the status of Christianity at the time. Upon failing to convince the established churches of the day that change or reform was necessary, they reluctantly split from the existing churches and formed their own. Sometimes the existing groups gave them a little shove. So, the history of Christianity is littered with reformers who have discovered "the truth" and "set the right course".

The problem is that an objective reading of the New Testament, does not provide any support for the idea of Christian denominationalism. Nor is there support for the idea that Christian doctrine is subjective and changeable. Spiritual truth is absolute. For each split there is either right and wrong or wrong and wrong.

Meanwhile, the Christian religion, more split and fractured than any other, is looked upon with derision by outsiders. We ask, why can't they get their act together. They claim to have the revealed TRUTH OF GOD, yet they cannot agree on a number of issues which should have been resolved centuries ago.
Examine everything carefully; hold fast to that which is good.
First Epistle to the Church of the Thessalonians
The truth will make you free.
Gospel of John

1John2_26
Guru
Posts: 1760
Joined: Sun Dec 04, 2005 6:38 pm
Location: US

Post #3

Post by 1John2_26 »

The problem is that an objective reading of the New Testament, does not provide any support for the idea of Christian denominationalism. Nor is there support for the idea that Christian doctrine is subjective and changeable. Spiritual truth is absolute. For each split there is either right and wrong or wrong and wrong.
Well presented McC.

You may be a former Christian, but you certainly know how to define it. Start with the truth and deviate from there. But the truth never moved.

User avatar
Cathar1950
Site Supporter
Posts: 10503
Joined: Sun Feb 13, 2005 12:12 pm
Location: Michigan(616)
Been thanked: 2 times

Post #4

Post by Cathar1950 »

You may be a former Christian, but you certainly know how to define it. Start with the truth and deviate from there. But the truth never moved.
I suppose you should be asked what is that unchanged truth and how would you ever know it?
It seems that would be true for Christians and non-Christians.
But it does not change his analysis does it? It is still valid.
What would make you think you would be any closer to the truth then anyone else?
Why would you think your denomination or your religion is any better off then all the rest?
If there is not a God wouldn’t that have been true from the beginning?
Makes me wonder what your point could ever mean beside some kind of tautology.

If there is one truth and everything and everyone changes including ideas, language, culture, religion, belief and writings (evolution?) how good can any of them have been in the first place? Are you getting closer or have you got it together? Looking at any claim today it looks like the sciences have come along better and faster in just the last 100 years. But I bet you wouldn’t put your faith (absolute trust with out reason, evidence and questions) in science.
I guess you should feel lucky (favored) that something else didn’t get to you first considering the lack of a clear guide and so many options.

So what is a true Christian and how do you know with out the bible, which is always going to be interpreted to prove some position or another?
I guess you can just write it off as the Holy Spirit but you would not be the first or the last and you could still no get everyone to join in. It almost starts to seem arbitrary.
It seems like if it faith (absolute trust with out reason, evidence and questions) really doesn’t require truth just belief in the truth even if it is wrong your still going to believe because that is true by your definition. How can you say a Mormon or some cult is wrong when their faith requires the same as yours?

1John2_26
Guru
Posts: 1760
Joined: Sun Dec 04, 2005 6:38 pm
Location: US

Post #5

Post by 1John2_26 »

Oooh, Cathar, "tautology?" Good for you. Learning the sophisticated way of insulting people personally? Now you're cooking.

Quote:
You may be a former Christian, but you certainly know how to define it. Start with the truth and deviate from there. But the truth never moved.

I suppose you should be asked what is that unchanged truth and how would you ever know it?
It seems that would be true for Christians and non-Christians.
But it does not change his analysis does it? It is still valid.
Test all things and hold firmly on to the stuff that's truth. Family, for example, is man-woman-children. It is one of thos immutable truths. But, wierdly, not for some people. A pregnant human woman always gives birth to a human child, or loses a human child in a mishap. But somehow some kinds of human people can claim that a woman doesn't carry a human within in her but some kind of mass.

I don't think faith and non-facts have anything to do with each other. Jewish people do not celebrate Passover out of faith. It really happened that story of the Israelites and the Egyptians.
What would make you think you would be any closer to the truth then anyone else?


Facts. Faith is something you purchase. You, "buy" into it.
Why would you think your denomination or your religion is any better off then all the rest?


Our faith. And of course, what it is founded on. The incessant attack on the "facts" of the "Christian faith" is the obsession of the anti-Christian. It is satanic in origin. "Is that what 'God' really said?"
If there is not a God wouldn’t that have been true from the beginning?
Only an insane person truly believes there is no God. At least that is my opinion and one of the Biblical authors I agree with. I have much experience to guide my assertion here, and remember I am a believer in God.
Makes me wonder what your point could ever mean beside some kind of tautology.


"Tautology." Gives me goosebumps. I'm so proud of you.
If there is one truth and everything and everyone changes including ideas, language, culture, religion, belief and writings (evolution?) how good can any of them have been in the first place? Are you getting closer or have you got it together? Looking at any claim today it looks like the sciences have come along better and faster in just the last 100 years.
I haven't seen science do much that has taken the facts out of God. I do not fear science at all. Only liberals using science for abominations. Do me a favor, hold your breath for fifteen minutes without breathing for any reason at all.

No cheating.

I'll do the same.

It will not be faith that kills us. It will be a natural scientifically proven process happening within our bodies, from denying outside forces. It will be our willingness to grasp ignorance and apply it to our bodies. I choose to study and grasp the truth when it is proven as such. Faith has absolutely nothing to do with Christ Jesus and those that follow God. Either Christ was crucified in reality of time and space, and resurrected in reality, in time and space and in the exact same way, that in reality the Sinai experience and all else happened to the Israelites happened in our time and space. There is no such thing as faith, if faith means believing in lies.

That, I'm sure, is why so much effort is put into disproving the "real" claims "in" the Bible.

In reality, there is good and evil. Liars are the bad guys 100% of the time. Of course the liars say that good and evil is interpretable. Of course.

The miracle of Jesus is immense, but the the one most "ignored" is the one about letting everyone grow old peacefully and die, without violenc eending their life. And in fact, doing good to the evil people even though they are evil people. A miracle is something that defies facts, not faith. I have faith that Jesus IS real.
But I bet you wouldn’t put your faith (absolute trust with out reason, evidence and questions) in science.


Biblical faith is better presented as "trust." Abraham trusted God. Remember that. It was by asking questions to God. Amazingly factual mathematic questions. "Would you destroy the city (of Sodom) if there were twenty good people there?"

It is lucky for earth that there are still left some good people. I do not doubt that the futility of atheist/scientists (humanism), to build a better world (as they envision it) would include genocide again if they had people convinced that it would work again.

Abortion is a horrific glimpse into the evil mind of madness that can look at truth and deny it. How many human beings have really been killed while being denied their humanity? Who knows? Those records are not kept. I do not have to doubt why. But claiming hundreds of millions of humans have been slaughtered on the alter of scientific ignorance called convenience and pro-choice, points faith at the non-Christian with 100% probability.

Just watch one pregnancy from conception to birth and you see that the blind faith of abortion supporters, is promoted by those that claim that condition exists in the Christian, when it has no similarity in meaning. Faith comes by reason, and reasoning facts.

What is fair for the Christian to hold dear, is that not evereyone will see "facts" the same. Abortion is the fine example to show where to place your trust and leave faith to the anti-Christian. Shaiking off the dust from your feet "so to speak." I trust that Jesus gave us that idiom to use when we get frustrated that people will choose lies to practice their ignorance wilfully. Usually humans just kill, enslave and subjugate those that do not follow the great leader. Jesus, inexplicably, told we Christians to let the anti-Christians go about their way unharmed. And to allow them to kill us when it is called for.

That is so mimicked these days by people that claim Christians are stupid as to be laughable. The feel good generation has grown up and had a kid or two. Now they practice a faith Cathar. A house built on sand so to speak. (Who was this Jesus guy with all of those cool sayings?)
I guess you should feel lucky (favored) that something else didn’t get to you first considering the lack of a clear guide and so many options.


God is God when I was a wild and crazy atheistic individual and when I came to the truth of God, as a Christian. I have all of the evidence to support the truth of God, even coming from my days denying the truth and living like a godless liberal justifying my actions by asking silly questions about there being proof for God. Science showed me the way during the enlightening process. Many beneficial people mimick Christ-like morality, because of absolutes and not the insanity of universalism.
So what is a true Christian and how do you know with out the bible, which is always going to be interpreted to prove some position or another?
It seems clear that the use of the term "interpretation" should be a warning flag that streaks for the sky the moment it is presented. The New Testament can be used as it is to define non- and anti Christians. It also seems quite clear that the Gospels and letters of the New Testament were written only for the reason of liars saying they were believers when they were not.
I guess you can just write it off as the Holy Spirit but you would not be the first or the last and you could still no get everyone to join in. It almost starts to seem arbitrary.
I will not discuss that aspect of God with a non-Christian, and only an orthodox one at that. With all due respect. I mean that.
It seems like if it faith (absolute trust with out reason, evidence and questions) really doesn’t require truth just belief in the truth even if it is wrong your still going to believe because that is true by your definition.
Where is "blind faith" taught in the New Testament or the Old Testament? It's OK to rant on about the news presented in the Bible, but clearly, it is meant as real happenings. Interesting the anti-Christian decries the deaths of Israel's enemies and supports abortion with tax dollars, and cares nothing about genocides waged throughout the world. It is sickening reality. So, it is reasonable to think about reality and the Bible as one and the same.

I just don't understand how anti-Christians come up with that faith thing? As can be seen in the struggle going on between Christians and evil people, Christians are more than happy to use science and study, but it is just denied on faith by their enemies, that the Christian is wrong. Evolution cannot possibly "ever" mean something from nothing. Why get all huffy and puffy about the silliness caused by Darwin? Science is no foe of Christians.
How can you say a Mormon or some cult is wrong when their faith requires the same as yours?
Mormons present evidnce in the Biblical realm that can be tested. It fails. If they want to cling to it, so be it. But it is still their facts presented against the evidence that disproves the Mormon assertion.

Did an Israelite ever write that God lives near a star called Kolob? Joseph Smith did.

Did the Israelites think God is having celestial sex with multiple wives and producing earth people? Joseph Smith did. Mormons cannot shake Smith from their religion. And that is just the tip of the Mormon theological iceberg.



"Tautology." I'm so impressed Cathar. Now apply that word's meaning to liberals, atheists, humanists, secularists, skeptics . . . ah, you know the rest . . . "Civil rights!" The redundant war cry for the hedonist and lascivious miscraent to force their faith be paid for by everyone. Even when scientific facts show the harm done by licentiousness, still the repetition ad infinitum, until ad nauseum is a reality. The cry of the anti-Christian faithful is as real as a fatherless child with siblings from many other women, or a person dying from an STD. It is the anti-Christian that walks by blind faith. But not really. Everyone knows the truth "in their hearts."

Colter
Apprentice
Posts: 207
Joined: Thu Sep 16, 2004 10:28 am
Location: Central Virginia

Post #6

Post by Colter »

Christianity itself is the very first digression from the religion of Jesus

Secondly and most importantly the true religion of Jesus is the relationship between the individual and God. It is a living, evolving religion characterized by unity not uniformity.

Christianity only mildly resembles the religion practiced by Jesus.


Colter

User avatar
Cathar1950
Site Supporter
Posts: 10503
Joined: Sun Feb 13, 2005 12:12 pm
Location: Michigan(616)
Been thanked: 2 times

Post #7

Post by Cathar1950 »

It doesn't take much to impress you does it John?
I use tautology because I didn't this circular captured enough.
I would have used tautological or tautologically but I was not sure of the spelling and didn't feel like looking it up.
You are probably more familiar with rhetorical tautology in the form of bible commentaries, topical bibles, index bibles, or sermons?
So if you are done hitting on me (it gives me the creeps)?

I want to know why you have to turn this thread into one of your homosexual or abortion agenda?
I don't think faith and non-facts have anything to do with each other. Jewish people do not celebrate Passover out of faith. It really happened that story of the Israelites and the Egyptians.
I am not sure you understand Passover on any level please do not presume to speak for Jews.
Facts. Faith is something you purchase. You, "buy" into it.
I am sure you do buy and purchase it and it is for sale.
Is that your endorsement? How 19th century Protestant, American evangelical, bible-believing enterpernual of you.

User avatar
KnowJah
Student
Posts: 59
Joined: Mon Aug 07, 2006 1:23 am
Location: California

Post #8

Post by KnowJah »

I myself believe I have the truth. Although sometimes I have doubts because I'm human, but I would never ever turn to any other religion becuase I am positive that none other is the true relgion.

melikio
Guru
Posts: 1715
Joined: Mon Apr 25, 2005 1:56 pm
Location: U.S.A.

Wiggle-room Please

Post #9

Post by melikio »

I myself believe I have the truth. Although sometimes I have doubts because I'm human, but I would never ever turn to any other religion becuase I am positive that none other is the true relgion.
It's so very "common" that many to MOST people who are religious DO feel, think or believe this way.

What's NOT reasonable (at all), is for them to believe that others do not feel, think or believe just as they do.

That should lead most "reasonable" people to some questions and ideas, which would serve to prove that others should be allowed a certain degree of wiggle-room, in reaching their own conclusions concerning religion or faith.

I just don't see where "Jesus" forced anyone to believe or do anything. And I think the truest "Christians" would understand the absolute value of that.

-Mel-
"It is better to BE more like Jesus and assume to speak less for God." -MA-

adlemi
Apprentice
Posts: 225
Joined: Thu Jul 27, 2006 10:33 pm

Re: Are There Any True Christian Denominations?

Post #10

Post by adlemi »

BeHereNow wrote:
I think that a biblical church is the correct demnomination.
The correct church is the church whose Leader, Good Pastor and Teacher, Overseer, and Keeper is the Lord God Jesus Christ himself. It is the Church of the Lord, the only church who has no man pastors because the Lord Jesus Christ is its only Good Pastor. See what the Lord Jesus is telling about His Church. The Lord said:


"Keep in your mind that in My Ministry or in My Church, all of you are equal with each other, none is above and none is below, none is rich and none is poor, none is short and none is tall, none is ill and none is healthy, all of you are at par with each other. If anyhow you are with impairment, you are still at same level with those who are without impairment because all of you are already healed spiritually. Because what you are feeling are only in flesh."

"I Am the Pastor. I Am the Good Pastor. Keep in your mind that there are no others who will teach you except Me. If ever that you will be explaining with each other, same will only be in accordance with your will, same will be in accordance with your own thinking. Hence, keep in your mind that whosoever will act being a pastor, who will act being a leader of My Church, he is doing iniquity and snatching away My post being the Good Pastor, who will act being a leader of My Church, he is doing iniquity and snatching away my post being the Good Pastor because you are only human beings, those of you who act as pastors, those of you who teach and standing up in front of many people, those of you who are doers of iniquities, those of you who cast out devils in My name. Keep in your mind that in My Second coming, many will call to Me saying, Lord, Lord, didn’t we do powerful works and in your name we cast out devils, we did healing. But keep in your mind, I will say to them, never at any time do I know you, I do not know you at any time, those of you who are habitual workers of iniquity, those of you who are casting out devils. Keep in your mind that if you cast out devils, you are snatching away the title role which properly belongs to Me only. If there is any being possessed by demon that you may encounter, you should only pray to Me and in that manner I Am ready to hear your prayer and I will hear your every plea that you will whisper to Me, that you will shout, that you will pray to. I will help you and I will never forsake you at any time much more to those people who are with Me and who follow Me."

Post Reply