Is hell eternal or not?

Exploring the details of Christianity

Moderator: Moderators

Post Reply
User avatar
scorpia
Sage
Posts: 913
Joined: Sat Sep 04, 2004 8:31 am

Is hell eternal or not?

Post #1

Post by scorpia »

Just a couple of references;
2 Thess 1 : 7-9 : and give relief to you who are troubled, and to us as well. This will happen when the Lord Jesus is revealed in heaven in blazing fire with his powerful angels. He will punish those who do not know God and do not obey the gospel of our Lord Jesus. They will be punished with everlasting destruction and shut out from the presence of the Lord and from the majesty of his power .
This verse mentions the final punishment as an everlasting destruction....
Jude 7 : In a similair way, Sodom and Gomorrah and teh surrounding towns gave themselves up to sexual immorality and perversion. They serve as an example of those who suffer the punishment of eternal fire
This verse is similair
Rev 20 :14-15 : The death and Hades were thrown into the lake of fire. the lake of fire is the second death. If anyone's name was not found written in the book of life, he was thrown into the lake of fire.
This verse however mentions the punishment as a "second death"

Perhaps the latter verse doesn't negate that the "second death" is eternal. But then how is death eternal? Does it mean a long eternal period in a process of dying? Or does it mean a person will for the rest of eternity be dead? Is hell eternal or not?
'Belief is never giving up.'- Random footy adverisement.

Sometimes even a wise man is wrong. Sometimes even a fool is right.

User avatar
Greatest I Am
Banned
Banned
Posts: 3043
Joined: Thu Jan 04, 2007 1:04 am

Hell is forever but it is good

Post #71

Post by Greatest I Am »

Eternity is grand if you can think demographycally well enough to envision it.
Hell is with us forever as are all the conceps that have here today. The thing of it is, is that it resides in heaven.
God is a greedy guy. Once he ownes something, he is loath to give it up.
To suggest that there is a place in his universe that is not his is to say that he is imperfect. This is not allowed. Otherwise we need to aswer as to what persentage of his holdings he is wllingto give up. That number of course is always 0.

Regards
DL

User avatar
MagusYanam
Guru
Posts: 1562
Joined: Mon Jan 17, 2005 12:57 pm
Location: Providence, RI (East Side)

Post #72

Post by MagusYanam »

Greatest I Am wrote:Eternity is grand if you can think demographycally well enough to envision it.
Hell is with us forever as are all the conceps that have here today. The thing of it is, is that it resides in heaven.
God is a greedy guy. Once he ownes something, he is loath to give it up.
To suggest that there is a place in his universe that is not his is to say that he is imperfect. This is not allowed. Otherwise we need to aswer as to what persentage of his holdings he is wllingto give up. That number of course is always 0.

Regards
DL
DL,

It appears you've put a new twist on Origen's line of thought. I think that his argument, though, was that God puts more value upon human beings than he does upon 'real estate'. Thus, God will not be satisfied in his perfect end unless all of those beings he created are in his care and by his side. To suggest otherwise would be to say that God's will is imperfect, or that his power and patience are imperfect in carrying it out.

It was this line of thought that gave rise to the theological standpoint now known as universalism.
If I am capable of grasping God objectively, I do not believe, but precisely because I cannot do this I must believe.

- Søren Kierkegaard

My blog

User avatar
scorpia
Sage
Posts: 913
Joined: Sat Sep 04, 2004 8:31 am

Post #73

Post by scorpia »

This new heavens and new earth is not like the afterlife described in the NT. Just what is this prophesy about?
Well you got me. In Revelations there is a mention of a new heaven and a new Earth and it's referenced again here, and there are some similairties (i.e. no more weeping), but then there might be some differences. To be honest though I believe that the prophecy is of Revelations because I was taught as such
'Belief is never giving up.'- Random footy adverisement.

Sometimes even a wise man is wrong. Sometimes even a fool is right.

User avatar
Goat
Site Supporter
Posts: 24999
Joined: Fri Jul 21, 2006 6:09 pm
Has thanked: 25 times
Been thanked: 207 times

Post #74

Post by Goat »

scorpia wrote:
This new heavens and new earth is not like the afterlife described in the NT. Just what is this prophesy about?
Well you got me. In Revelations there is a mention of a new heaven and a new Earth and it's referenced again here, and there are some similairties (i.e. no more weeping), but then there might be some differences. To be honest though I believe that the prophecy is of Revelations because I was taught as such
The Revelation of John has so many metaphores and poetic imagry, how can you be sure what it is indeed talking about?

I have seen it claimed that it was actually talking about the political situation in Rome at the time, and the beast was 'nero', with the seven gates being the seven gates of Rome.

User avatar
Beta
Scholar
Posts: 468
Joined: Sun Jul 31, 2005 11:07 am
Location: West Yorkshire, UK

Post #75

Post by Beta »

to get back to the original question - is hell eternal ?

Hell-fire or the lake of fire is eternal, many scriptures say so.
But it is not what most christians think it is - IT IS NOT ETERNAL TORMENT.
Etrnal punishment is absolutely not eternal torment for humans, for the simple reason they are matter and the material we are made up of burns up to leave nothing more than ASH. Mat.25v41, the wicked will share the everlasting fire prepared for the devil and his angels but they are spirit-beings and man is not -(until res.to et.life)
Read Mal.4v3 , and you (the resurrected Saints) shall tread down the wicked (the unrepentant sinner) for they shall be ashes under the soles of your feet in the day that I shall do this says the Lord of hosts (in the day they are consigned to the lake of fire because of an unrepentant attitude, an unwillingness to learn of God).

The punishment is eternal death , not eternal torment for man.
The wicked are never given immortality, they never receive spirit-status , only the obedient believer shall put on ommortality in the resurrection to eternal life.1Cor.15.

The whole reason for man to have been created physical in the first place is so he can be returned to his original state of non-existance (dust and ashes Gen.3v19) , if he does not by his own free will seek godly perfection. Even though God does not want contrary rebellious children in his kingdom neither does he want them to suffer eternally. False teaching has caused people to form a false concept of a loving merciful God.

User avatar
achilles12604
Site Supporter
Posts: 3697
Joined: Mon Jun 19, 2006 3:37 am
Location: Colorado

Post #76

Post by achilles12604 »

Beta wrote:to get back to the original question - is hell eternal ?

Hell-fire or the lake of fire is eternal, many scriptures say so.
But it is not what most christians think it is - IT IS NOT ETERNAL TORMENT.
Etrnal punishment is absolutely not eternal torment for humans, for the simple reason they are matter and the material we are made up of burns up to leave nothing more than ASH. Mat.25v41, the wicked will share the everlasting fire prepared for the devil and his angels but they are spirit-beings and man is not -(until res.to et.life)
Read Mal.4v3 , and you (the resurrected Saints) shall tread down the wicked (the unrepentant sinner) for they shall be ashes under the soles of your feet in the day that I shall do this says the Lord of hosts (in the day they are consigned to the lake of fire because of an unrepentant attitude, an unwillingness to learn of God).

The punishment is eternal death , not eternal torment for man.
The wicked are never given immortality, they never receive spirit-status , only the obedient believer shall put on ommortality in the resurrection to eternal life.1Cor.15.

The whole reason for man to have been created physical in the first place is so he can be returned to his original state of non-existance (dust and ashes Gen.3v19) , if he does not by his own free will seek godly perfection. Even though God does not want contrary rebellious children in his kingdom neither does he want them to suffer eternally. False teaching has caused people to form a false concept of a loving merciful God.
After many reading on this subject and being gently corrected by my fellow Christians here I agree with this view. I hope this was an easier change for you than me. I had to admit I was WRONG! :(
It is a first class human tragedy that people of the earth who claim to believe in the message of Jesus, whom they describe as the Prince of Peace, show little of that belief in actual practice.

User avatar
joer
Guru
Posts: 1410
Joined: Thu Mar 02, 2006 4:43 am
Location: Santa Rosa, CA

Post #77

Post by joer »

Howdy Tambi and all. I hope all are well. Progressing into the New Year with Flair!

Tambi wrote:
well you have to admit, people who believe others burn in damnation hell fire for eternity simply for following a slightly different religious tradition do have a rather morbid theological world view
I agree

Tambi wrote:
ahh, I see what you're saying, so people who do good works for purely selfish motives, like personal salvation, or worldy status right?
Exactly!

Tambi wrote:
evangelical Christians for one. they believe that truth and spiritual knowledge is dead outside of their faith, thus the need to go forth and convert the masses to Christ.
Now I get where you’re coming from. You right those who do that are forgetting that God Loves us all and Jesus came for all of us. Not just a special few. Before we are Christians we are children of God. Along with ALL our brothers and sisters in the world regardless of faith or non-faith.

Tambi wrote:
Orthodox ecangelical Christians believe that we have only one life to accept Christ, and that christianity is the only ticket to escape hell.
They may believe that, but they must offer eternal life to ALL, not just Orthodox believers in Christ. It’s not for them to judge who will be saved and who won’t. That judgement belongs to God alone. If we follow Christ’s teachings our only task is to offer eternal life we don’t need to teach only a few will be saved. God will make that determination. We must offer a Gospel of Love that Christ taught to replace the Gospel of Fear that was taught in olden times.

Tambi see what you think about this story. Read it like fiction. But remember sometimes you find more Truth in Fiction than in the crystallized dogmas of the institutions guided by men.
While the religion of authority may impart a present feeling of settled security, you pay for such a transient satisfaction the price of the loss of your spiritual freedom and religious liberty. My Father does not require of you as the price of entering the kingdom of heaven that you should force yourself to subscribe to a belief in things which are spiritually repugnant, unholy, and untruthful.[/b] It is not required of you that your own sense of mercy, justice, and truth should be outraged by submission to an outworn system of religious forms and ceremonies. The religion of the spirit leaves you forever free to follow the truth wherever the leadings of the spirit may take you. And who can judge--perhaps this spirit may have something to impart to this generation which other generations have refused to hear?

Shame on those false religious teachers who would drag hungry souls back into the dim and distant past and there leave them! And so are these unfortunate persons doomed to become frightened by every new discovery, while they are discomfited by every new revelation of truth. The prophet who said, "He will be kept in perfect peace whose mind is stayed on God," was not a mere intellectual believer in authoritative theology. This truth-knowing human had discovered God; he was not merely talking about God.

I admonish you to give up the practice of always quoting the prophets of old and praising the heroes of Israel, and instead aspire to become living prophets of the Most High and spiritual heroes of the coming kingdom. To honor the God-knowing leaders of the past may indeed be worth while, but why, in so doing, should you sacrifice the supreme experience of human existence: finding God for yourselves and knowing him in your own souls?

Every race of mankind has its own mental outlook upon human existence; therefore must the religion of the mind ever run true to these various racial viewpoints. Never can the religions of authority come to unification. Human unity and mortal brotherhood can be achieved only by and through the superendowment of the religion of the spirit. Racial minds may differ, but all mankind is indwelt by the same divine and eternal spirit. The hope of human brotherhood can only be realized when, and as, the divergent mind religions of authority become impregnated with, and overshadowed by, the unifying and ennobling religion of the spirit--the religion of personal spiritual experience.

The religions of authority can only divide men and set them in conscientious array against each other; the religion of the spirit will progressively draw men together and cause them to become understandingly sympathetic with one another. The religions of authority require of men uniformity in belief, but this is impossible of realization in the present state of the world. The religion of the spirit requires only unity of experience--uniformity of destiny--making full allowance for diversity of belief. The religion of the spirit requires only uniformity of insight, not uniformity of viewpoint and outlook. The religion of the spirit does not demand uniformity of intellectual views, only unity of spirit feeling. The religions of authority crystallize into lifeless creeds; the religion of the spirit grows into the increasing joy and liberty of ennobling deeds of loving service and merciful ministration.


Tambi I think you and many here are ready to follow "the religion of the spirit" and no matter what church or faith you belong to it will make you a better person in the faith or church you follow.

By the way I'm not a universist. I have a peticular faith and Church I follow. But by findng and living the living faith. one person at a time we will change our churches from Crytallized Dogma to Churches of living faith. It's our job to change them into Loving Churches who teach us to LIVE as jesus taught not dogma About jesus. The Time has come for the world to change. the time is NOW.

Tambi wrote:
do you believe that anything remotely similar to Hell exists, or that there are any consequences in the afterlife for our actions in the world?


Here’s an excerpt of my views from page 2 of this thread.
http://debatingchristianity.com/forum/v ... 4528#54528

My preception of these ideas evolves with accruement of knowledge and entertainment of varying ideas over time.
Sin - to me is making a mistake or missing the mark, like in old Anglo times when a arrow "sinned", it missed the mark. So basically when your doing something "wrong" instead of "right" and "wrong is basically "missing the mark". That’s Sin.
Now when we do something wrong we "suffer" the consequences of that wrong doing.
So Hell- to me is "suffering the consequences" of our "wrong" doing. It's really kind of a natural occurrence. It's not imposed on us by GOD but is a result of our "free will" choice. God doesn't make us choose wrongly, we do it on our own.Now some of us constantly and consistently choose to do the "wrong" thing. Maybe some of you can conceive of such a person. Maybe a hardened criminal, repetitive murderer, some person who shows no remorse and has no intention of ever changing. This might be a person who would "suffer" the consequences of their actions as long as they're alive. And if they lived eternally it might be referred to as an "Eternal Hell".

God Blessings with with you and all on this site.

User avatar
Beta
Scholar
Posts: 468
Joined: Sun Jul 31, 2005 11:07 am
Location: West Yorkshire, UK

Post #78

Post by Beta »

achilles12604 wrote:
Beta wrote:to get back to the original question - is hell eternal ?

Hell-fire or the lake of fire is eternal, many scriptures say so.
But it is not what most christians think it is - IT IS NOT ETERNAL TORMENT.
Etrnal punishment is absolutely not eternal torment for humans, for the simple reason they are matter and the material we are made up of burns up to leave nothing more than ASH. Mat.25v41, the wicked will share the everlasting fire prepared for the devil and his angels but they are spirit-beings and man is not -(until res.to et.life)
Read Mal.4v3 , and you (the resurrected Saints) shall tread down the wicked (the unrepentant sinner) for they shall be ashes under the soles of your feet in the day that I shall do this says the Lord of hosts (in the day they are consigned to the lake of fire because of an unrepentant attitude, an unwillingness to learn of God).

The punishment is eternal death , not eternal torment for man.
The wicked are never given immortality, they never receive spirit-status , only the obedient believer shall put on ommortality in the resurrection to eternal life.1Cor.15.

The whole reason for man to have been created physical in the first place is so he can be returned to his original state of non-existance (dust and ashes Gen.3v19) , if he does not by his own free will seek godly perfection. Even though God does not want contrary rebellious children in his kingdom neither does he want them to suffer eternally. False teaching has caused people to form a false concept of a loving merciful God.
After many reading on this subject and being gently corrected by my fellow Christians here I agree with this view. I hope this was an easier change for you than me. I had to admit I was WRONG! :(
I am absolutely overjoyed at your change of heart and the new concept you will gain of a loving, caring, compassionate God who lives up to his name of love and mercy.
So much erronious teaching of eternal torment has ruined many people who turned off God or accepted it as a way of godly justice. God gets no pleasure from human suffering and most certainly not for all eternity.
Changing one's long-held beliefs is never easy but it's what we must do if God opens our eyes. God bless you !

User avatar
joer
Guru
Posts: 1410
Joined: Thu Mar 02, 2006 4:43 am
Location: Santa Rosa, CA

Post #79

Post by joer »

Beta wrote:
I am absolutely overjoyed at your change of heart and the new concept you will gain of a loving, caring, compassionate God who lives up to his name of love and mercy.

So much erronious teaching of eternal torment has ruined many people who turned off God or accepted it as a way of godly justice. God gets no pleasure from human suffering and most certainly not for all eternity.

Changing one's long-held beliefs is never easy but it's what we must do if God opens our eyes. God bless you !
Amen Beta! I couldn't agree more! :D

User avatar
Madeline
Apprentice
Posts: 221
Joined: Sun Oct 15, 2006 3:57 am
Location: U.S. (From Cheshire, England)

Post #80

Post by Madeline »

I was thinking about this one verse in the Old Testament....

Daniel 12:2—And many of them that sleep in the dust of the earth shall awake, some to everlasting life, and some to shame and everlasting contempt.

That's the one. Hmmm....seems pretty clear to me! =)

Love,
Madeline

Post Reply