Can AI decide who won a debate?

[historia]

Aside from this, you definitely have not refuted my other given point(s). Please actually address them.

Whether I have refuted you or you have refuted me is up to each person to decide, whoever is ultimately right.

So, one of the things I've been thinking about lately is using AI to judge who 'won' a debate on this forum. Instead of letting each reader decide that for themselves, can we turn to bots to give us a more neutral judgement as to who at least made the better arguments?

Question for debate

Can artificial intelligence accurately and fairly judge who won a debate on this forum?

[William]

Sure. Let's let AI decide. It needs to say why one lost and the other won

No. It is "we" who are arguing which "need" that input.

Nothing nefarious mind you - just checking out the tools and devices...

It is a matter of engaging, not disengaging but as you likely noticed the word is almost the same as "gagging"

"It's a gag gag gag!

[William]

[Replying to William in post #88]

I'm not going to play these games, William.

Okay Jason.

But I know you do...

I will no longer be discussing with you on this thread.

What are you? A seer?

Here is the chat transcript, as promised: https://chat.deepseek.com/share/26kq5h1bbtlyu75ac8.

Don't know that there is now any point in taking a look...

What would QueenBee tell us?

Later, My Friend...